8 Best Substitutes for Apple Butter


Apple butter is a fundamentally highly concentrated apple sauce formed due to prolonged cooking of apples with either cider or water till the sugar in the apples caramelizes, turning the apple butter a deep brown.

Apple butter is not butter, and its thick, spreadable soft consistency term gives it a butter-like texture.

Apple butter seasoning with spices such as cinnamon, clove, and other additional spices, such as cloves, nutmeg, and nutmeg, add texture and unique flavor.

Culinarians use apple butter in various dishes, from spreading as a buttered piece of bread; it is also often mixed into simmering liquids or frosting to bring sweetness and complexity to grilled and roasted meats.

Apples are, however, seasonal fruits, and many time people find scarce in packaged apple butter.

Homemade apple butter is also prone to spoilage and takes a lot of cooking time, So many people consider different alternatives for apple butter.

8 Best Substitutes for Apple Butter

This list comprises the best substitute for apple butter.

Apple Sauce

Apple sauce, by their definitions, is a sauce made up of apples.

Apple sauce is made with peeled or unpeeled apples and can be spiced or sweeten in their nature (depending on the spices added).

Apple sauces are usually inexpensive and readily available in the market.

Apple sauce is versatile; apple sauce adds flavor in pork and goose meat and potatoes and pasta and goes well with the blood sausage.


Apple sauce taste is similar to apple butter and is extensive in cooking in baked goods such as cakes, pastries, and bread. Their texture and the easy-to-make recipe make them a favored substitute for apple butter.


Buttermilk is considered fermented milk . After great churning of milk, buttermilk, savory in taste, is produced.

Buttermilk has a soft, creamy liquid texture. This texture, when added to the dishes, adds more moisture and fluffiness to the baked good.

Buttermilk’s slightly sour flavor adds a pleasant zest to baked goods such as cakes, bread, biscuits.

Due to its nature of origin, buttermilk is usually low in fat.

They soften gluten when added to baked goods, giving baked goods a softer texture and more shape.


Buttermilk is a good substitute for almost all baked goods and is commonly available in markets and stores. Giving quick rise to the bread makes an excellent substitute for apple butter in cakes, cookies, and biscuits.


Pumpkin has been traditionally in use for centuries for its edible fruit and seeds also, and they are very versatile in their use for cooking.

Pumpkin seeds and pumpkin puree both are excellent substitutes for apple butter.

Pumpkin seeds can be added, dried, and cooked to create savory and sweet dishes, including cereal, granola, salads, and vegetables.

Pumpkin butter and puree both create a similar texture to apple butter brings significant moisture, a similar flavor, and a fine texture to the baked goods.

Adding a combination of cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and cloves in pumpkin puree creates pumpkin butter.

Pumpkin butter is a great alternative, adds flavor to various dishes and drinks such as cocktails, toasts, bread, and desserts; it also works as a cheese substitute in pizza.


Pumpkin butter and pumpkin puree are a substantial substitute for apple butter in almost any meal. Pumpkin butter acts like a natural oil that adds extra moisture and a delectable flavor to the dish., muffins, and other baked items cakes and cheesecake recipes.

Olive Oil

Olive oil results from extraction from ripe fruits of the olive tree, Olea europaea , is part of a simple, light, and calm cuisine, with defined tastes and full of harmony so-called Mediterranean cuisine.

Olive oil’s unique flavor results from its natural form that makes it different from other oils.

Olive oil is an adequate substitute for baking bread, making pizza, and pasta dough for cookies and fudge.

Olive oil fat is considered “good” fat, unlike butter, since it adds extra antioxidants and vitamin E baked goods.

Vitamin E in olive helps keep muffins and pieces of bread fresher, longer.


Olive oil adds a unique flavor and texture to cookies and bread. It is easily accessible in the market, makes it an excellent substitute for apple butter. Olive oil fruity aroma can also bring out other flavors commonly used in baked goods, like chocolate, nuts, spices, and fruit.


Butter is a derived product of fat and protein from milk.

Butter is very versatile; Butter physically remains solid in a refrigerator but quickly softens and spread at room temperature; it further melts to a thin liquid consistency when put in hot weather.

Butter helps in creating tenderness in baked goods.

Melted butter is a vital ingredient in the preparation of sauces and for sauteing and frying.

Butter adds texture to cookies and baked goods and creates a “melt in your mouth. It brings fluffiness and a variant spark of flavors to the dish.


Butter works as a critical moisture ingredient in most dishes. Its simple flavor and readily available quality make it an excellent apple butter substitute.

Vegetable Oil

Vegetable oils are usually edible plant source oil that fruits, seeds, and oils produce .

Vegetable oils are known for their use in foods since prehistoric times.

Some of the most common liquid vegetable oils used in the culinary are soybean, canola, sunflower, cottonseed, and corn.

Canola is a kind of vegetable oil that is highly favored in baking to provide moisture and a neutral taste.

Since vegetable oils have a higher smoke point, they apply in various dishes.
Coconut oil is physically hard at room temperature, so it is similar to butter in its complex form.

Vegetable oil is famous for its no taste, which works well efficiently for all the recipes.


Vegetable oils are primarily cheap and available at every grocery store. Vegetable oil is an excellent substitute for a variety of cake flavors, from chocolate and vanilla to carrot and spice, and thus works well in place of apple butter.


Yogurt is a resulting product from culturing a mixture of milk with lactic acid-producing bacteria, such bacteria that help make yogurt are known as yogurt cultures .

Yogurt is well known for its beneficial health properties, such as improved intestinal health and immune system.

All types of milk make yogurt. There are now various yogurts available worldwide, ranging from low-fat, flavored fruit to Greek yogurt.

Yogurt provides many nutrients to children and adolescents’ diets, such as protein, calcium, vitamin B12, and phosphorus.

Yogurt is a superfood when it comes to aiding baking; they provide rich creaminess that helps keep baked goods moist.

Yogurt imparts savory tanginess that provides old fashion, mouth-watering flavor to the cake.

Yogurt also makes baked goods fluffy and light in texture.


Yogurt is known for its famous flexibility to acquire in any dish and produce a satisfying result. From a garnish in ice cream or whipped cream topping to adding fluffiness in baking, yogurt works as a magical ingredient substituting apple butter.


Avocado is distinct as a member of the flowering plant family Lauraceae .

Avocado is not characteristically sweet or salty; it has a distinctive subtly flavored, with defined texture.

The avocado fruit pulp is oily and highly nutritious, with richness in minerals and vitamins.

Avocados enhance the texture of baking goods and make them moister.

It works as an excellent spread in place of jam.

Avocado provides a similar effect as butter in baking dishes; it is the healthiest natural fat.

Avocados don’t require to puree because they are ready when mashed and mixed with the rest of the ingredients as long as it ripens.


Avocados provide similar features, texture, taste, and fluffiness to the apple butter in a recipe. Avocados addition in the baking is identical to adding pumpkin puree in the baking. Many vegans and vegetarians use avocado as a vegan substitute; its nutritional value provides the apple butter’s healthiest replacement.


What is the critical difference between apple butter and applesauce?

Apple butter and apple sauce are very similar, as apple sauce concentration is apple butter. However, apple butter is more deeply caramelized with various nuts and spices, making it different in consistency, flavor, and dish use.

How does Apple butter taste?

Apple butter is an undiluted apple sauce made from boiling apples at a very high temperature and then gradually allowing it to settle.
It has a hint of warm cinnamon spice, added in its making process along with other herbs and sugar, but it mostly tastes like apples. It’s a very intense apple flavor because it is essentially just apples cooked down and concentrated to their essence.

Bottom Line

Apple butter is a great vegan substitute for eggs in various bakery goods and produces warm, soothing flavor jams and side dis

hes. While Apple butter does contain some sugar, it also provides a lot of fiber that aids in digestion and vitamins B and C.

There are, however, many substitutes available in place of apple butter for providing moisture and texture in baking.

Show Some Love by Sharing!

About Karen Wilson

Karen is a foodie to the core. She loves any variety of food - spicy or junk! Her slender body and height are deceiving, as she enjoys eating hearty meals that would leave most people gasping for air. She has an appetite for life, and wants everyone around her to share in it too.