8 Best Substitutes For Shiitake Mushrooms


This blog is the ultimate guide on what are the Substitutes of Shiitake Mushrooms and how you can replace them with ease and safety at your home.

I have personally tried this myself numerous times, and it always works like a charm. You can totally rely on these substitutes as they are Chef’s choices.

It is time for the first step, which is getting to know all kinds of substitutes of Shiitake Mushrooms that are available.

Eight Best Substitutes For Shiitake Mushrooms

The best substitutes for shiitake mushrooms – Portobello Mushrooms, Cremini mushrooms, Porcini Mushrooms, Dried for fresh shiitake mushrooms, Oyster Mushrooms, White button mushrooms, Tempeh, and Zucchini.

They are discussed in detail here – 

Portobello Mushrooms

The Portobello mushrooms are otherwise called field or Giant Cremini Mushrooms. They’re only the mature adaptation of cremini Mushrooms.

They’re another appropriate substitution from the shiitake as they’re bigger and completely developed mushrooms.

Portobello mushrooms have a beefy surface and exceptionally substantial taste.

These kinds of mushrooms can be utilized when you are roasting, grilling, or baking.

Portobello Mushrooms are accessible in all seasons. You can discover them in the local markets.

In recipes that require shiitake, Portobellos can be utilized as the best substitution since it’s a more extensive, thoroughly developed rendition of the shiitake.

How to substitute

To use in the dishes, add the Portobello mushrooms likewise while observing the taste until it reaches your preferred levels. Utilize equivalent amounts when subbing white Portobello mushrooms for Shiitake Mushrooms. A lot of the Portobello mushrooms can overwhelm the entire dish since it has a higher fixation.

Ever used Portobello mushrooms before? Check out how to properly prepare and learn to cook Portobello mushrooms by “America’s Test Kitchen” here:-

Cremini mushrooms

The Cremini Mushroom is a mature form of mushroom.

Their marginally more developed state implies a browner tone, firmer surface, and preferable flavor over the younger white mushrooms.

They’re utilized now and again in stews and soups since they hold up better in the fluid.

They can be somewhat chewy for specific individuals, so be cautious when subbing since they probably won’t appreciate it.

Cremini mushrooms are ideal for stews, pasta sauces, risotto, or grill as they will add a rich taste.

They can be tracked down everywhere in the world, and you will love utilizing them.

How to substitute

Utilize cremini mushrooms as a 1:1 substitute for Shiitake Mushrooms. Contingent upon the measure of food, you can compare the necessary shiitake mushrooms with the perfect measure of cremini mushrooms.

Confused about how to use Cremini mushrooms for a recipe? Check out this video by “Ed’s Kitchen Simple” showing how to make a healthy and tasty Cremini mushroom:-

Porcini Mushrooms

Porcini mushrooms are brown-caped, normal in European food.

These mushrooms are round, meaty, delicate, and smooth, considered a decent substitute for shiitake mushrooms.

With their nutty and strongly rich flavor, it draws out a great desire for your dish.

In European cooking, these mushrooms are a mainstream fixing.

Likewise, another utilization is in the brown sauces, and they can likewise give out a solid flavor in barbecued steaks.

Also, porcini mushrooms fit well with meat burgers, pasta, and risotto.

You can settle on porcini mushrooms for your recipe when shiitake mushrooms are inaccessible.

How to substitute

One gram of fresh Shiitake Mushroom is equal to one gram of porcini Mushrooms, half-gram of cremini mushrooms, and a little of tempeh. A significant hint which you need to realize is that prior to cooking, you need to eliminate the stems and the vertical tubes cooking.

Confused about how to use Porcini Mushrooms? Look no further and watch this video by “Giallo Zafferano Italian recipes” talking about how to clean Porcini Mushrooms prior to cooking it for any dish, here:-

Dried for fresh shiitake mushrooms

Even though they are the same thing, dried and fresh shiitake mushrooms are extraordinary.

They can fill in as a substitute for one another, yet the dried mushrooms have a more grounded smell and flavors rather than the fresh ones.

You put dried shiitake mushrooms in water to mellow them so you can cut them without any problem. prior to cooking, wash them in cool water for around 15 to 20 min.

They are a typical fixing in numerous Chinese dishes so that you can utilize both as a substitute for one another.

Utilize these choices to cook soups, stews, and a lot more recipes.

How to substitute

The replacement is essential; follow the 1:1 proportion. A lot of the dried shiitake mushrooms can overwhelm the entire dish since it has a higher fixation, so add just a small amount at a time.

Watch “Fun, healthy Chinese Cuisine Ambassadors” to know how to prepare a delicious dried Shiitake mushrooms for a quick and easy dinner, here:-

Oyster Mushrooms

Oyster mushrooms are another substitution that can be utilized when there are no shiitakes.

They grow on trees and have scallop-like covers with a blanketed dark tone.

You can utilize them as a substitute in many dishes, and you should be cautious when setting them up as it might take more time to cook, so watch out for them so you will not burn them.

They have got an extremely gentle and unpretentious taste like fish.

The motive behind why they’re so uncommon and one of a kind is a result of their surface, which is extremely substantial, and it ought to be appropriately ready.

How to substitute

You can use one gram of the Oyster mushrooms to substitute for one gram of clean, fresh Shiitake mushrooms. If you cook it in a curry, make a point to cook through the dish.

Want to know about how you can use Oyster mushrooms for any recipe? Check out this video by “The Georgia Straight” giving you tips and tricks on how to peel, clean, and cook Oyster mushrooms here:-

White button mushrooms

White Button Mushrooms are otherwise called regular mushrooms or champignons.

These are the most promptly accessible kind of mushrooms in the stores that are accessible throughout the entire year.

White button Mushrooms are typically radiant white and what makes them extraordinary is their fragile, gentle flavor and fine surface.

Likewise, they are a similar size to Shiitake mushrooms.

When you analyze these two kinds, you can see the comparability and simultaneously the things that make them a decent substitute for one another.

If the recipe asks for Shiitake mushrooms, you can generally utilize white button ones in grills, pasta dishes, and sautés.

How to substitute

Measure out an equal proportion of this white button mushroom to the amount of Shiitake Mushrooms your recipe calls for, but add it gradually. If you continue gradually adding your white button mushrooms and tasting your dish as you add it, you can ensure that the flavor of this white button mushroom does not overpower your finished dish.

Want to know how White button mushrooms can be prepared in a recipe? Watch “Something’s cooking with Alpa” step by step showing us how to clean fresh white button mushrooms prior to cooking and storing the mushrooms, here:-


Tempeh also makes a great alternative for those who don’t like Shiitake’s texture.

Tempeh additionally makes a great option for individuals who don’t care for Shiitake’s surface.

Tempeh is the best non-mushroom substitution.

It’s nothing but an ideal decision since it likewise possesses a flavor like mushrooms, regardless of containing no mushrooms.

Furthermore, tempeh is overflowing with umami, which gives it a concrete surface and flavor.

It fits well in dishes, and it is apt for those with mushroom allergies.

Even though it is not as known as any other alternative, it is similarly pretty much as viable as a shiitake substitute.

How to substitute

Combine four parts of tempeh with one part of Shiitake Mushrooms for an easy substitute when you are in a hurry. This ratio will create a very nice flavor for whatever dish you are mixing up. It is also easy to make whatever quantity of tempeh you need using this ratio.

Want to know how to make a bowl of tempeh? Check out this video by “Veganlovlie – Vegan Fusion – Mauritian Recipes” and enjoy preparing an easy and tasty tempeh at home:-


Zucchini is a mid-year vegetable, a herbaceous plant whose natural fruits are reaped when their young seeds and epicarp are still soft and edible.

It is a great decision to find a way into most recipes that require any shade of Shiitake.

Add it to your recipe for a more similar flavor.

Zucchini is a flexible ingredient that can be made in essentially any form. They are delicious when stuffed!

Rather than adding sweet, herbaceous taste to food, it assumes different kinds of fixings.

Zucchini can add tone to sautés and give a surface to meals or any appetizing prepared dish.

How to substitute

To use in the dishes, add the Zucchini while observing the taste until it reaches your preferred levels. In many cases, For one gram of fresh and raw shiitake mushrooms, use a gram of tasty and healthy zucchini. You can chop the vegetables or supplement them in a different way and eliminate the peel prior to cooking the food.

Do you know where to use Zucchini in a recipe? Check out “Allrecipes” telling you about the many ways in which you can incorporate Zucchini in various recipes, here:-


Are cremini mushrooms the same as Shiitake Mushrooms?

No, Cremini Mushrooms are simply baby Portobello mushrooms. Cremini mushrooms are like brown button mushrooms; however, they have a more rounded flavor and a meatier surface. Meanwhile Shiitake Mushrooms have a solid taste that stands up well to tasty sautéed foods like hamburgers Shiitake and snow pea recipes.

What is the main difference between Portobello Mushrooms and Shiitake Mushrooms?

Portobello mushrooms are an adult type of normal white or crimini mushrooms. Meanwhile Shiitake mushrooms, high in iron and pressing a smoky flavor, are local to Asia and have a round cap with a dull underside. Portobello mushrooms are bigger in size, meaty in texture, and almost neutral in flavor.

What is the difference between shiitake mushrooms and regular mushrooms?

Shiitake Mushrooms are different from other sorts of mushrooms with a more intense mushroom taste, practically woody flavor. The shiitake mushroom is incredible for bringing a great deal of flavor and has a surface that is chewier than it is spongy. You can easily distinguish them from the regular mushrooms.

Bottom Line

I hope this detailed guide helped you in finding substitutes for Shiitake Mushrooms with ease.

Attempt these Shiitake Mushrooms substitutes and let us know the outcomes in the remark area beneath. Which one replacement worked out to be the awesome you? If you think about some other unimaginable substitute, do impart to us.

If you think these substitutes would be helpful for your family and friends, do share them with them.

Show Some Love by Sharing!

About Marie Thomas

Marie is a food enthusiast who has always wanted to have her own food blog. She loves cooking and experimenting with new recipes, and she can't wait to share them with the world when she finally launches her blog! When Marie isn't in the kitchen cooking up something delicious or writing about her adventures at home or on vacation, you might find Marie taking care of her family and enjoying time with friends.