Can You Freeze Banana Pudding?

By

Quick Answer: Can You Freeze Banana Pudding?

Yes, you can absolutely freeze banana pudding! While freezing can affect the texture, consistency and general appearance of the pudding, freezing and thawing it following the right techniques and properly going through the steps can reduce these changes to a minimum.

If you have made lots of banana pudding to serve for an occasion later on, you can even freeze the banana pudding to save time, space, money, effort and cut down waste!

Although not very highly recommended owing to how banana pudding has a very high-water content that can entirely alter the texture, flavor and taste of your pudding after freezing and thawing; if desperate times call for it to not waste food, we must rise to it.

Read on to find out everything you need about freezing and defrosting banana pudding, and how to properly do each of these, sourced from time-tested experience and research.

What to Note and Do Before Freezing Banana Pudding

Some things you should expect when freezing banana pudding include the fact that some of its individual ingredients may not freeze well; especially things like custard, which can even separate once thawed.

Whipped cream does not do a great job of freezing either.

Additionally, even the bananas are very likely to turn into a mushy consistency and a generally unappetizing brown color, after defrosting and being exposed to air.

Also consider the other ingredients that may be temperature-sensitive: milk, cream, eggs.

The cookies and wafers tend to absorb most of the moisture when freezing, leading to the banana pudding losing out on its distinguishable texture entirely.

Since freezing leads to moisture crystallizing, it is highly likely that the texture would be lost.

So, what is the other alternative?

Refrigerating your banana pudding to elongate its shelf life does not only alter the taste the longer it is kept in the fridge, the pudding also absorbs fridge aromas, altering the taste of your pudding itself, possibly rendering it inedible.

Therefore, freezing your banana pudding seems to be the safest bit, although clearly, it isn’t without its vices.

As long as you are extra mindful of the steps and tricks, you can minimize possibilities of the freezing going wrong. Read on to find out exactly how.

Can You Freeze Banana Pudding?

Can You Freeze Banana Pudding?

Active Time: 30 minutes
Total Time: 30 minutes

Materials

  • All your necessary ingredients for banana pudding according to your recipe
  • Small dish
  • Lemon juice
  • A sturdy spoon
  • Airtight freezer-safe container
  • Cling wrap

Instructions

Freezing works significantly better if you are working with homemade banana pudding, as you can prep the ingredients on your own to an extent, and make them more suitable for freezing.

Read this step-by-step guide to find out how.

  1. Dip banana slices into lemon juices – Before you begin prepping to actually make your banana pudding, dip the banana slices into a small dish containing lemon juice.

    The citric acids in the lemon juice prevents oxidation from happening to the banana once it comes into contact with air after defrosting.

    The banana will retain its natural light color instead of turning into a muddy, unappetizing brownish tint.
  2. Mash ingredients, make banana pudding – Make your banana pudding as you would, closely following the recipe.
  3. Transfer into airtight container – Once the pudding has been made and is ready to freeze, transfer it immediately into an airtight freezer container, using a sturdy spoon. Remember, the fresher it is when kept in the freezer, the better it will freeze.
  4. Cover container with cling wrap, secure lid and freeze – Once you have put the pudding inside the container, cover the mouth of the container securely with cling wrap.

    Then secure the lid tightly, making sure it is airtight and watertight.

    Ensure you have sealed it carefully. Label the container, and it is ready to freeze!

Freezing Store-Bought Banana Pudding

Time Taken: 15-30 minutes

What You Need:

  • A sturdy spoon
  • Airtight freezer-safe container
  • Cling wrap

This is much harder to freeze as all the ingredients have already been assembled into pudding, leaving you no chance to prep them beforehand to ensure better freezing.

It is also tricky and not recommended to freeze store-bought banana pudding in the packaging or container it came in, as chances are that the original packaging does not provide your dessert with enough protection during freezing.

Therefore, if you have a choice between making banana pudding yourself at home or buying it from the store, especially if you are looking to keep the dessert in freezer storage at least for a while, it is always a better idea to go with homemade.

You can still freeze store-bought banana pudding. Just follow these steps carefully, and remember to consume it as early as possible within freezing it.

Transfer Into Airtight Container

Use a sturdy spoon to transfer the banana pudding immediately into an airtight freezer container.

Remember, the fresher it is when kept in the freezer, the better it will freeze

It is a better idea, therefore, to freeze the store-bought banana pudding at the earliest since the time it is bought and opened.

Cover Container with Cling Wrap, Secure Lid and Freeze

Once you have put the pudding inside the container, cover the mouth of the container securely with cling wrap.

Then secure the lid tightly, making sure it is airtight and watertight.

Ensure you have sealed it carefully. Label the container, and it is ready to freeze.

How to Freeze Bananas for Pudding

Time Taken: 15-20 minutes

What You Need:

  • Resealable airtight freezer bags or containers
  • Knife

You can freeze bananas to make pudding later on as well!

This is actually a great idea as bananas can be frozen for up to a year, given you follow the steps correctly and carefully.

Not only pudding; you can also use frozen bananas in smoothies, to bake banana bread, or simply as frozen bananas to dip in chocolate and enjoy as a lovely sweet snack!

There are several ways to freeze bananas, but read on to find out about the most efficient, time-tested and convenient one.

Slice the Bananas

Slicing bananas has proved to be the best way to freeze them. It is all the more helpful if you are freezing the bananas to use them particularly for pudding later on – it saves so much time and energy!

Transfer the Banana Slices into Airtight Freezer Bags or Container

Once you have put all the slices into the bag or the container, seal it very carefully and tightly to make sure it is airtight and watertight.

Label and Freeze

Label the container or bag with a marker, and it is ready to freeze!

You can keep the bananas in freezer storage for up to a year or even more, but it is best to consume them within 6 months from freezing for optimum freshness, taste and flavor.

How Long Can You Freeze Banana Pudding?

Banana pudding does not, strictly speaking, freeze well, and will not keep in the freezer for an extended period of time.

Hence, it is recommended that you consume the banana pudding within 1 to maximum 2 weeks for optimum flavor.

The longer you keep it in the freezer, the more it is going to lose its texture, consistency, flavor and taste as the ingredients will start to lose moisture, separate, and get spoilt.

How to Store Frozen Banana Pudding?

Banana pudding can be kept in freezer storage in airtight containers, as prescribed in the methods above.

Please note, that whether or not you are freezing store-bought or homemade banana pudding, cover the container with cling wrap.

Other freezer storage tips include to ensure that the temperature in the freezer remains consistent, and that the sealing has been done securely and carefully.

How to Defrost Frozen Banana Pudding?

Defrosting banana pudding is a fairly easy process. Just make sure you thaw it very carefully so that the dessert does not get mushy.

Simply transfer the frozen banana pudding from the freezer to the refrigerator and leave it to thaw overnight. Once thawed, serve and eat the pudding immediately.

In case you are in a hurry, you can try to speed up the thawing process by submerging the container with the pudding, in a bowl of lukewarm water.

Avoid using warm or hot water, and never microwave frozen banana pudding.

Can You Re-freeze Frozen Banana Pudding?

Re-freezing banana pudding is not recommended at all.

Freezing once would be hard enough on the texture as it is; to thaw it and then freeze again only to defrost another time, would simply ruin the texture of the banana pudding entirely and make it inedible.

Avoid re-freezing at all costs; once thawed, serve immediately and do not refreeze any leftovers.

Does Banana Pudding Freeze Well?

Banana pudding, unfortunately, does not freeze well; the texture keeps changing considerably depending on the amount of time it is kept inside the freezer, and especially considering the kind of ingredients used.

It is considered safest to eat the banana pudding within a maximum of 2 weeks since freezing.

FAQs

How do I know if my banana pudding has gone bad?

As banana pudding is largely made of perishable items such as milk, cream and other dairy products, it is a good idea to inspect it carefully for signs of it getting bad before you eat it.

If there is any discoloration or signs of bacterial growth, you should do away with it. If the smell is off, or if the taste is off, as in, sour or bitter, it is a good idea to discard the pudding.

Can I freeze banana bread?

Yes, you can freeze banana bread. It actually freezes a lot better than banana pudding, and just in general has a longer shelf life.

What else can I do with leftover banana pudding if I choose to not freeze it?

There are lots of alternatives in case you decide to not go with freezing your banana pudding.

How long can I keep banana pudding in the refrigerator?

Banana pudding will stay good in the fridge for up to 4, to a maximum of 5 days.

Can I leave frozen banana pudding to thaw outside on the kitchen counter?

Absolutely not, avoid it at all costs. You can refrigerate to thaw the frozen banana pudding overnight.

Bottom Line

We have gone through the methods to freeze banana pudding, along with bananas to make pudding from, as well as a number of other guidelines and things you need to keep in mind while freezing them.

We hope that this guide has helped you understand how to freeze banana pudding safely at home.

If this article was insightful and helpful for you, please share it with your friends and family, and feel free to leave any questions or inputs you have in the comment section below!

References

Show Some Love by Sharing!

About Amanda Jones

Amanda is a person with an eye for detail. She has been cooking since her childhood and loves to bake too. Recently, she's made the decision to pursue baking full-time and quit her 9 to 5 job. In the meantime, she still enjoys cooking and baking for friends and family, especially when it comes time for special occasions like birthdays or holidays!

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Skip to Instructions