Best Hoop Cheese Substitutes

By

Whether you have run out of Hoop cheese or can’t find it at stores near you, this substitution guide will get you covered. 

So, let’s dive right into it. 

Best Hoop Cheese Substitutes

The Best Hoop Cheese Substitutes are- Cottage Cheese, Ricotta Cheese, Farmer’s Cheese, Cheddar, Tofu, Cashew Cheese, Pot Cheese, and Paneer.

They are discussed in detail here-

1. Cottage Cheese 

Mild and slightly salty, the creamy cottage cheese is one of the best alternatives to Hoop cheese in most of your recipes.

The dry cottage cheese is the best option to get as close to the Hoop cheese texture and consistency as you want and it goes well in almost any Hoop cheese recipe.

How to Substitute? 

You can replace Hopp cheese with equal measures of dry cottage cheese. But if you are using regular cottage cheese, you might want to cut down on the moisture elements in the recipe to get the right consistency. 

Check out this cottage cheese pasta recipe by “From Scratch Fast” on YouTube – 

2. Ricotta Cheese

Ricotta is yet another mild and creamy cheese with hints of saltiness that can perfectly replace Hoop cheese in most of its recipes.

It is versatile and you can use it in both sweet and savory recipes as a substitute.

How to Substitute? 

Much like cottage cheese, you can replace Hoop cheese with a 1:1 ratio of Ricotta cheese, as long as you cut down on the other moisture elements. Ricotta cheese is comparatively higher in moisture than Hoop cheese.

Here is a Ricotta cheese grilled cheese sandwich recipe that you can try instead of the Hoop cheese recipe – 

3. Farmer’s Cheese 

Hoop cheese is a kind of farmer’s cheese, so you can confidently use farmer’s cheese as a substitute in most recipes.

It is mild and creamy with notes of tanginess, that can go well in both sweet and savory recipes. It also melts like a charm and is perfect to cook with.

How to Substitute? 

You can replace Hoop cheese with the same measure of farmer’s cheese in your recipe. But keep in mind that at times farmer’s cheese is made with additional salt, so you might want to adjust the seasoning accordingly.

4. Cheddar Cheese

Mild and creamy with good melting properties, Cheddar cheese is the ideal substitute for Hoop cheese in recipes like mac and cheese or grilled sandwiches.

Young or less mature Cheddar is the perfect choice to get the right flavor and creaminess. 

How to Substitute? 

You can replace Hoop cheese with equal measures of Cheddar cheese in almost any recipe. Keep in mind that as the Cheddar cheese ages it gets harder in texture and sharper in flavor. 

For a Cheddar cheese alternative to the Hoop cheese mac and cheese recipe, check out this YouTube tutorial – 

5. Tofu 

For vegan foodies, tofu can replace Hoop cheese in certain recipes. For sandwiches or grills, you can use tofu as a great alternative with its mild or rather bland flavor and semi-firm texture.

But if you are looking for a melty alternative, tofu might not be the best choice. 

How to Substitute? 

In sandwiches or pasta recipes, you can use tofu in equal measure. Since it does not melt well, you can blend the tofu thoroughly for a more even consistency in the recipe. You might also want to adjust the seasoning to counter the bland taste of tofu in the recipe.

Here is a super quick grilled Tofu sandwich recipe to try instead of a Hoop cheese one – 

6. Pot Cheese

Pot cheese is much like cottage cheese or ricotta with mild flavors, hints of tanginess, and creamy texture.

It works well in most Hoop cheese recipes, like pasta or lasagna.

It is drier than cottage cheese or ricotta so, is closer to Hoop cheese in terms of consistency.

How to Substitute? 

You can replace Hoop cheese with a 1:1 ratio of Pot cheese. But keep in mind that pot cheese is more sour or tangy than Hoop cheese, so you might want to adjust the seasoning of the recipe accordingly. 

7. Paneer

Yet another cottage cheese variety that you can use as a Hoop cheese substitute is Paneer.

Its bland taste and chewy texture make it ideal for fillings or sandwiches.

However, if you are looking for melting cheese, paneer is not a good choice. 

How to Substitute? 

In a recipe that does not call for melting cheese, you can replace Hoop cheese with equal measures of Paneer. But because of its bland taste, you might want to add more salt and seasoning to get the right flavors. 

8. Cashew Cheese

For a vegan and quick-fix Hoop cheese alternative that you can use for almost any recipe, you can try the cashew cheese.

Although there might be flavor differences, it gives you perfectly yummy results.

You can use this cheese for most Hoop cheese recipes like sandwiches, mac and cheese, or even bakes. 

How to Substitute? 

You can replace Hoop cheese with equal measures of Cashew cheese. But depending on the consistency of your cashew cheese recipe, you might want to add more or little to get the right moisture level in your recipes. 

Check out this fun video on a Cashew cheese-based mac and cheese recipe that you can try at home – 

Bottom Line 

I hope this quick guide has given you the right and easily accessible cheese alternative to Hoop cheese. 

If you would like to share some alternatives or recipes of your own, it would be lovely to hear from you. 

Feel free to share this article with your cheese-loving family and friends. 

Show Some Love by Sharing!

About Irene Clark

Irene is a supermom of 4 kids who always has a smile on her face. She's an amazing dancer - you should see her moves! - and she loves to eat, especially with wine. She also loves pop music and travels across the country with her family and friends.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.